Nature-based outperforms technology
Why constructed wetlands lead in performance and operational reliability
Constructed wetlands are among the most effective systems for decentralized wastewater treatment. In addition to very good effluent quality, they are particularly characterized by high process stability and above-average reliability in complying with regulatory limit values. A solid basis for this is provided by the study “Operational and performance efficiency of fully biological small wastewater treatment plants up to 50 PE” (German, BDZ, IWS 2014), conducted with the participation of the Leipzig University of Applied Sciences, which comparatively evaluated different plant types.
Figure: mean COD in treated wastewater outflows by treament type
Effluent quality is consistently high.
The results show that constructed wetlands achieve the best effluent values, particularly for chemical oxygen demand (COD). Not only is the median of the measured values low, but the variability is also small. Particularly noteworthy are the results demonstrating that high treatment performance is reliably achieved even under unfavorable operating conditions. Thus, constructed wetlands not only deliver good average results but also ensure effluent quality during peak loads and non-steady-state operating phases.
A key advantage lies in the very low probability of exceeding regulatory limits. Compared to technical small-scale treatment plants, constructed wetlands show significantly fewer outliers. These systems are less sensitive to hydraulic and organic load fluctuations and maintain the required effluent standards even under irregular feeding or partial load operation.
Process stability and technical robustness
The reasons for this high operational reliability lie in the inherent properties of constructed wetlands. The interaction of filtration, adsorption, and biological degradation processes within the filter body creates a highly resilient treatment system. The vegetated soil filter acts simultaneously as a hydraulic and biological buffer, while the biofilm in the root zone ensures stable degradation processes.
In contrast, technical small-scale treatment plants depend on functioning aeration, control systems, and mechanical components. As a result, they are more sensitive to operational disturbances, failures, or improper handling. Constructed wetlands, on the other hand, operate largely without active mechanical equipment and therefore exhibit significantly lower susceptibility to failure.
Advantages in permitting and energy consumption
This results in clear advantages for planning and permitting. Constructed wetlands provide high verifiability of compliance with regulatory limits, reduce the risk of operational disturbances, and enable long-term stable plant operation.
In addition, nature-based systems have significantly lower energy demand per cubic meter of treated wastewater or can even operate entirely without electricity under gravity flow conditions.
The results of the study are consistent with more than 30 years of experience of Janisch & Schulz. In practice, it is evident that constructed wetlands demonstrate their strengths under real operating conditions over the medium and long term, delivering consistently reliable effluent quality.
Do you find this information relevant?
… then subscribe to our Newsletter and don’t miss any of our new publications.
See you soon!
